When reading the About page over at awardsdaily, I realized that my site is the oldest perpetually-running Oscar fansite on the internet AND the UAADB is the longest perpetually-running Oscar discussion board/forum on the Internet.
Now, this is based on my own knowledge of what's out there. There could be others that have been around longer, but I can't think of them. Gold Derby/The Envelope started later, Oscar Watch started 1999 (3 years after mine, 1 year after the UAADB).
Let me know what else is out there for longer or close to around the same time.